The tried and true recipe for love - aphrodisiacs, booze, and fire. Here are five bars that have the romance trifecta of oysters, cocktails, and a fireplace.
Grand Army Bar
Enjoy raw oysters, shellfish towers and craft cocktails served fireside in a cozy setting. This Brooklyn Heights bar has the power team of restaurateurs Noah Bernamoff (Mile End), Julian Brizzi (Rucola), and barman Damon Boelte (Prime Meats) running the show.
"Grand Army Bar is one of my favorite places. They are focused on oysters and cocktails, but they have a phenomenal wine list, very good beer and a functioning fireplace. It is very romantic and quaint."
FED Pro > Bartender Ivy Mix of Leyenda
One of the first craft cocktail bars to open in the Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens area. Order fresh East Coast oysters, sip on a Champagne cocktail and canoodle on one of their Victorian love seats.
"Always welcoming and always great cocktails, but really good food too."
FED Pro > Bartender Tristan Willey of The Long Island Bar
A former longshoreman’s bar that was built in the1900s and served the dock workers at the nearby East River shipyards. It’s been renovated, but still feels like a neighborhood bar. Fireplace, hot toddies, East Coast oysters, and a wine list created by FED Pro sommelier Lee Campbell.
This tiny gem of a bar is just slightly larger than a phone booth, but it’s dark and hidden away in Times Square. Have a little romance without the crowds and order an historic classic cocktail and some raw or gratin oysters from their small plate menu.
"A jewel of a spot with flawless cocktails. Have something regal."
FED Pro > Bartender Tom Richter of Dear Irving
This art deco, Prohibition-style bar wins for having one of the better looking fireplaces in NYC. Order their Oysters on the Half Shell with Mignonette & EO Bloody Mary Mix.
"Great drinks, great vibe, and awesome steak tartare."
FED Pro > Chef Missy Robbins
"If there was an award for best night out, Employees Only would wine it."
FED Pro > Bartender Sean Muldoon of The Dead Rabbit
DISCOVER OUR FED 24-HOUR GUIDES
NEW YORK FED FEATURES